Different routes of prescribing in Homeopathy

यूटा मॆटिल की पोस्ट , ’ To swallow or not to swallow…that is the question!’ कई अर्थों मे महत्वपूर्ण है । अधिकतर होम्योपैथ दवाओं को oral route यानि मुँह द्वारा ही लेने की सलाह देते हैं जैसा कि यूटा के एक सर्वे से स्पष्ट है । स्वंय हैनिमैन ने भी आर्गेनान सेक्शन २७२ में इस तथ्य को रखा है :

In Aphorism 272 he describes to the homeopath that a “granule placed dry on the tongue, is one of the smallest administrations for the less severe, only recently developed cases of disease” [10] (p.158). He goes on to point out that as such, only few nerves are touched by the medication. Further he describes that if the granule is dissolved in water and is prior to repeated ingestion succussed; a much stronger medication is created of which even the tiniest dose comes into instant contact with many nerves [10]. Yet, this also does not deliver indications for a definite necessity of transmucosal absorption.

लेकिन इसके बावजूद हैनिमैन ने चिकित्सकों को अन्य routes को भी अपनाने की सलाह भी दी  है जिनमें olfaction method प्रमुख है । पिछ्ले वर्ष से अब तक स्वंय मैने भी इस तथ्य को क्लीनकल प्रैक्टिस मे अनुभव किया कि कई होम्योपैथिक दवायें olfaction method से बेहतर कार्य करती हैं जैसे कि acute respiratory infections विशेषकर acute asthma ( दमा ) मे Ipecac 0/3 से 0/10 . arsenic 0/5, और sambucus 0/3 मुँह द्वारा प्रयोग करने की अपेक्षा nebulizer route से अधिक प्रभावी साबित होती है । इसका कारण क्या हो सकता है , इसके बारे मे तो अगर और अधिक रिसर्च हों तो शायद कहना मुमकिन हो ।
फ़िलहाल यूटा मॆटिल की पोस्ट , ’ To swallow or not to swallow…that is the question!’ का आंकलन करें उनके ब्लाग http://cleverhomeopathy.wordpress.com
पर ।

Clever Homeopathy


A high degree of satisfaction is reported by patients of the homeopathic approach to health care [11]. Hahnemanns [10] postulations in Aphorism 2 of the Organon insist on a treatment that acts “in the shortest, most reliable and least detrimental of ways” (p.35). The routes by which remedies are administered can influence patient satisfaction with a regimen.

Central to this essay lies the question of the efficacy of the oral transmucosal remedy delivery over the oral swallow method. It is a common belief that, in homeopathic practice, an administered remedy needs to be dissolved on or under the tongue, such that absorption of the active properties via the oral mucosa is established. A survey has been conducted amongst practicing homeopaths evaluating their beliefs and experiences. The alternative routes of remedy delivery and the prevalence of the oral route have been identified via a second survey undertaken amongst suppliers of…

View original post 3,379 और  शब्द


2 responses to “Different routes of prescribing in Homeopathy

  1. Dear Dr. Tandon – Namaste

    I thanking you very much for posting your very informative article
    which is appreciated very much.

    With best regards

    Homoeopathically yours
    Dr. Sayeed Ahmad

  2. Thank you Dr. Tandon!
    Thank you for sharing this insight! Interesting, that the usage of a nebuliser shows better results in your practice, perhaps it has something to do with the delivery of the remedy by dispersion in such small droplets…it is a form of remedy delivery that I think I should keep in mind for the future, for my patients with similar complaints.

एक उत्तर दें

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / बदले )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / बदले )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / बदले )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / बदले )

Connecting to %s